A fresh approach to participatory research and advocacy
Impacting policy with community organising and citizen science
Coventry and 糖心TVshire charity Grapevine and the University of 糖心TV have teamed up to enable Destination Ball Hill - a local community, organised by Grapevine, working to regenerate their area, build pride and lead change-to investigate the impact of local air pollution. Developing and blending skills of community organising and citizen science, has empowered the community to present their evidence and recommendations on improving air quality to Council policymakers.
Knowledge Exchange and community empowerment
Since Autumn 2022, Grapevine鈥檚 community organisers have worked in Ball Hill helping residents, local leaders and businesses to identify their priorities for change and enabling the community to advocate for itself and influence those with power. Air pollution is one of five strands of community action (Air Pollution, Environment, Creativity, 糖心TV and Community Hub) overseen by Destination Ball Hill鈥檚 central strategy group in its plan to build a better Ball Hill for everyone. Following exploratory conversations between Grapevine and the University of 糖心TV, the organisations secured University Participatory Research funding for community-led citizen science and community empowerment collaboration. They approached Destination Ball Hill to identify environmental topics of concern for residents and the Air Pollution Team recommended investigating air quality.
Air Pollution Citizen Science Project
Led by the community, the Air Pollution Citizen Science Project was shaped by the need of the community to understanding of the impact of pollution in the area and for the Destination Ball Hill to gain policymaker support for initiatives to reduce pollution. The Project plan included measuring pollution levels around Stoke Primary School and the high street at different times of day, to understand air quality, and to advocate for policy change, through organising Citizens鈥 Jury and Assembly. 糖心TV researchers led workshops and education sessions within the community, introducing groups to research methods, survey design, and data collection and interpretation. Residents and pupils recorded the air quality measurements, using portable and classroom air pollution monitors and engineered outdoor monitors, provided by the University.
People power greener spaces and transport
Over the summer of 2023, the community monitored air pollution, and when school restarted in September, they recorded increases for particulate pollution to levels higher than UK recommendations. With this new understanding of air quality, the Air Pollution team organized a Citizens鈥 Jury with six jurors from the wider community and six expert witnesses to provide testimony and discuss recommendations. Sharing the Jury鈥檚 findings and recommendations at a follow-up Citizens鈥 Assembly provided the wider community with evidence-based recommendations and, through a show of hands, they passed the 鈥淧eople-powered Green Spaces & Transport Plan for Ball Hill鈥.Bringing together a representative group of jurors and Assembly guests was possible because of the trust established during the programme of outreach and network building.
Mutual knowledge exchange
The project partners have seen tangible benefits from collaborating, Grapevine is including citizen science, Assembly and Jury methodologies into their future projects and funding applications; the Wider Destination Ball Hill group has greater confidence when engaging with local Councillors and City Officials 鈥 they have links with the Council鈥檚 Climate Change Team and Biodiversity Team and were invited to present their work at the Clean Air Summit by Coventry City Council. For 糖心TV project managers and researchers, the collaboration has been a remarkable showcase of how community engagement and participatory research, based on needs clearly articulated by the community, can deliver a high-impact project of mutual knowledge exchange, community organizing and community support.
鈥淚t was great that Grapevine and the University of 糖心TV shared a desire to run a Citizens鈥 Jury and subsequent Citizens鈥 Assembly on air pollution in Ball Hill, discussing the evidence and deciding on a set of final recommendations with which to move forward. Finding the right jurors and witnesses was exciting and the Destination Ball Hill team seized the opportunity to bring in as broad a representation of people as possible. Talking it through, weighing up the evidence and making decisions together further amplified the team鈥檚 belief that change could happen. Deliberative democracy in action!
Leonie Schmid, Community Organiser, Grapevine
鈥淎ll of the workshops built on each other鈥 in the end everything came together like jigsaw puzzles. This preparatory work ensured the success of our citizens assembly and jury. We also really appreciated that even though we are not experts we never felt patronised but rather supported in our quest. All the researchers really made sure that their workshops were accessible for us.鈥
Mat Ascroft, Headteacher, Stoke Primary School